|T O P I C R E V I E W
||Posted - Feb 08 2012 : 7:44:02 PM
i really like your feature of selecting a bunch of lines, then press / and all of them get a // in front.
however, style-cop insists on having 4 slashes when it's at the beginning of a line.
i am suggesting a flag in the VA options to choose whether one wants 2 or 4 slashes.
|9 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First)
||Posted - Feb 29 2012 : 1:11:53 PM
case=64628 is implemented in build 1901
HKEY_CURRENT_USER\\Software\\Whole Tomato\\Visual Assist X\\VANet10
DWORD value: LineCommentSlashCount
default is 2
Replace VANet10 with appropriate subkey for other IDEs (VANet9, VANet8, VANet, VA6)
||Posted - Feb 29 2012 : 06:57:06 AM
i just that a registry option (LineCommentSlashCount) was implemented in version 1901. thanks a lot! the quick response is much appreciated!
||Posted - Feb 10 2012 : 9:24:17 PM
thanks a lot for making it a feature request and for the suggestions. i will try them.
||Posted - Feb 10 2012 : 11:29:26 AM
As a temporary work around, you can use an IDE macro to comment and uncomment like this. Here is an initial attempt at a macro to do this, which I have tested in VS2008 with C++ code:
' select a block of lines and then trigger this
' it comments out code lines and uncomments comment lines
Public Sub ToggleCommentStyleCop()
Dim objTxtSel As TextSelection = DTE.ActiveDocument.Selection
Dim colRanges As TextRanges = objTxtSel.TextRanges
Dim objRange As TextRange
Dim pointStart, pointEnd As EditPoint
For Each objRange In colRanges
Dim nLineLength As Integer = objRange.EndPoint.AbsoluteCharOffset - objRange.StartPoint.AbsoluteCharOffset
If nLineLength > 0 Then
pointStart = objRange.StartPoint
pointEnd = objRange.EndPoint
Dim strLine As String = pointStart.GetText(pointEnd)
Dim RegexObj As New System.Text.RegularExpressions.Regex("^[\\t ]*////")
If False = RegexObj.IsMatch(strLine) Then
' work out what the line should turn into
' by removing only the leading / characters
Dim nCommentPos, strBeforeComment, strAfterComment
nCommentPos = InStr(strLine, "/")
strBeforeComment = Mid(strLine, 1, nCommentPos - 1)
strAfterComment = Mid(strLine, nCommentPos + 4)
' then replace the line with the new version
pointStart.ReplaceText(pointEnd, strBeforeComment & strAfterComment, vsEPReplaceTextOptions.vsEPReplaceTextKeepMarkers)
It probably has a few edge cases it does not handle correctly, but hopefully this will help for now. If the macro does something useful for you on your syste, you can bind a keyboard shortcut to this macro, so you can trigger it directly.
||Posted - Feb 10 2012 : 07:56:17 AM
I have put in a feature request to see what the developers make of it:
For now, you can use the uncomment feature to uncomment a commented block:
Edit -> Advanced -> Uncomment selection
You can assign a single shortcut for them, since they are also commands like the other menu items: Edit.CommentSelection and Edit.UncommentSelection. Use the following dialog to bind the shortcuts:
Tools -> Options... -> Environment -> Keyboard
||Posted - Feb 09 2012 : 2:57:46 PM
i can use the ide's "Ctrl E, C" twice around a selection. that does the trick. but requires five key presses compared to pressing VA's / twice.
BUT - and this really makes the ide's Ctrl E,C a non-solution - it does not operate as a toggle. when i want to remove the comments i have to tediously select and remove them manually.
i have been a loyal customer for many years, paying my yearly subscription. this is the first time i am requesting a feature. this feature can be added in 10 minutes tops, since it doesn't effect anything else and the logic is already there. all you have to do is output 2 more / based on checking a check-box, which you can bind to a boolean.
i thought it wasn't too much to ask. guess i was wrong...
||Posted - Feb 09 2012 : 12:38:10 PM
Thank you for the detailed description. And what about Edit -> Advanced -> Comment menu, which can be bound to a keyboard shortcut, and does a very similar thing? Generally, we try to avoid adding too much option to the option dialog, and also, this request is a kind of special case. Or pressing star over a selection is an another way to deal with this situation. It surrounds the code with the other style of comment.
||Posted - Feb 08 2012 : 10:26:37 PM
style-cop enforces code style (not content, just looks) guidelines developed (and used) by microsoft. most of the .NET libs are written with it.
style-cop has no settings whatsoever. nothing can be configured. my current contract (C# and C++) enforces style-cop.
at first it is a huge pain in the ass because some of the rules are indeed way over the top and seem ridiculous. but now that i have used it for a while i must say the core set of rules it enforces makes my code much more readable and maintainable. i am seriously contemplating using it even for my private projects.
with regard to most of the rules VA is not in the way at all. in fact it is a great help, as it always has been.
it is just this comment with // thing that bugs me. i figure it is a very simple mod in your code. just make it an option in the "General" section of VA options. something like "use //// instead of //". shouldn't take more than 10 minutes to implement and test - et voila!
hope this helps.
i am sure there are others here who use style-cop (voluntarily or not) who would appreciate it. this is my second contract where the company insists on using it...
||Posted - Feb 08 2012 : 9:00:26 PM
I would like to understand your background, first. I have never used style-cop myself, and I'm wondering if wasn't it be easier to just change this setting in the program? I mean, it is possible? Or is your company also expect you to use this style?
Have you tried Edit -> Advanced -> Comment selection (or the keyboard shortcut for it)?